| Fairfax County | 59,787 | 31.7% | Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. 29% |
| Virginia Beach City | 31,676 | 35.7% | Humana Inc. 48% |
| Chesterfield County | 29,559 | 38.5% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Henrico County | 28,072 | 41.6% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Prince William County | 24,606 | 37.1% | Humana Inc. 27% |
| Chesapeake City | 19,305 | 39.8% | Humana Inc. 38% |
| Norfolk City | 19,294 | 50.1% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Richmond City | 19,216 | 53.1% | Humana Inc. 35% |
| Loudoun County | 18,202 | 32.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Newport News City | 16,554 | 50.0% | Humana Inc. 42% |
| Hampton City | 14,138 | 49.1% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Roanoke City | 11,515 | 52.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Spotsylvania County | 10,152 | 35.6% | Humana Inc. 48% |
| Portsmouth City | 10,082 | 52.1% | Humana Inc. 35% |
| Hanover County | 9,823 | 36.3% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Roanoke County | 9,745 | 37.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 33% |
| Bedford County | 8,939 | 37.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 54% |
| Suffolk City | 8,838 | 41.9% | Humana Inc. 36% |
| Washington County | 8,698 | 54.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 52% |
| Arlington County | 8,550 | 29.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 32% |
| Pittsylvania County | 8,341 | 47.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Lynchburg City | 8,044 | 49.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 55% |
| Henry County | 7,775 | 50.7% | CVS Health Corporation 45% |
| James City | 7,534 | 30.3% | Humana Inc. 38% |
| Stafford County | 7,465 | 31.2% | Humana Inc. 44% |
| Franklin County | 7,408 | 45.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Wise County | 7,361 | 70.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 46% |
| Frederick County | 7,191 | 31.9% | Humana Inc. 47% |
| Danville City | 7,136 | 63.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 27% |
| Tazewell County | 6,840 | 57.0% | Humana Inc. 41% |
| Alexandria City | 6,403 | 29.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 31% |
| Augusta County | 6,350 | 30.2% | Humana Inc. 38% |
| Rockingham County | 6,230 | 30.1% | Humana Inc. 49% |
| Campbell County | 5,966 | 42.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 65% |
| Albemarle County | 5,915 | 22.4% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Montgomery County | 5,522 | 35.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Petersburg City | 5,495 | 72.8% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Russell County | 5,200 | 66.3% | Humana Inc. 41% |
| Scott County | 4,801 | 73.0% | Humana Inc. 51% |
| Mecklenburg County | 4,619 | 45.9% | Humana Inc. 39% |
| Smyth County | 4,562 | 52.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 60% |
| Lee County | 4,466 | 69.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 62% |
| Wythe County | 4,451 | 53.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 50% |
| Halifax County | 4,438 | 43.5% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Shenandoah County | 4,339 | 36.0% | Humana Inc. 44% |
| Pulaski County | 4,286 | 45.5% | Elevance Health, Inc. 31% |
| Fauquier County | 4,265 | 27.4% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Buchanan County | 4,195 | 65.3% | Humana Inc. 42% |
| York County | 4,120 | 26.1% | Humana Inc. 42% |
| Accomack County | 4,092 | 39.4% | Humana Inc. 44% |
| Louisa County | 4,070 | 37.7% | Humana Inc. 49% |
| Isle of Wight County | 4,056 | 37.8% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Culpeper County | 3,913 | 32.8% | Humana Inc. 54% |
| Orange County | 3,844 | 36.8% | Humana Inc. 36% |
| Amherst County | 3,794 | 43.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 61% |
| Gloucester County | 3,734 | 34.4% | Humana Inc. 41% |
| Botetourt County | 3,724 | 38.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 38% |
| Warren County | 3,629 | 40.4% | Humana Inc. 53% |
| Carroll County | 3,510 | 39.8% | Humana Inc. 36% |
| Dickenson County | 3,351 | 72.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 58% |
| Caroline County | 3,085 | 42.4% | Humana Inc. 52% |
| Martinsville City | 2,961 | 74.6% | CVS Health Corporation 36% |
| Bristol City | 2,801 | 62.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 49% |
| Salem City | 2,782 | 42.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 33% |
| Dinwiddie County | 2,735 | 40.3% | Humana Inc. 54% |
| Staunton City | 2,721 | 38.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Patrick County | 2,716 | 49.8% | CVS Health Corporation 46% |
| Goochland County | 2,653 | 27.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 36% |
| Hopewell City | 2,649 | 54.8% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Prince Edward County | 2,534 | 47.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 47% |
| Page County | 2,523 | 37.3% | Humana Inc. 44% |
| Powhatan County | 2,450 | 31.4% | Humana Inc. 34% |
| Harrisonburg City | 2,440 | 40.6% | Elevance Health, Inc. 45% |
| New Kent County | 2,378 | 33.8% | Humana Inc. 36% |
| Waynesboro City | 2,368 | 43.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 32% |
| Fluvanna County | 2,343 | 31.5% | Humana Inc. 44% |
| Manassas City | 2,274 | 39.7% | Humana Inc. 31% |
| Prince George County | 2,258 | 30.7% | Humana Inc. 51% |
| Brunswick County | 2,195 | 49.9% | Humana Inc. 36% |
| Rockbridge County | 2,184 | 32.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 37% |
| Charlottesville City | 2,181 | 32.5% | Humana Inc. 34% |
| Westmoreland County | 2,122 | 35.3% | Humana Inc. 48% |
| Winchester City | 2,053 | 35.5% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Grayson County | 2,007 | 40.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 54% |
| Giles County | 2,001 | 42.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 29% |
| Fairfax City | 1,992 | 40.2% | Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. 24% |
| Northampton County | 1,961 | 44.0% | Humana Inc. 39% |
| Appomattox County | 1,881 | 42.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 58% |
| Nelson County | 1,836 | 34.3% | Humana Inc. 39% |
| Floyd County | 1,814 | 38.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 39% |
| Buckingham County | 1,807 | 44.8% | Humana Inc. 36% |
| Fredericksburg City | 1,786 | 36.5% | Humana Inc. 45% |
| Colonial Heights City | 1,770 | 41.8% | Humana Inc. 44% |
| Nottoway County | 1,742 | 45.3% | Elevance Health, Inc. 40% |
| Southampton County | 1,721 | 36.2% | Humana Inc. 47% |
| Northumberland County | 1,698 | 32.8% | Humana Inc. 36% |
| King William County | 1,667 | 37.9% | Humana Inc. 42% |
| Amelia County | 1,649 | 44.3% | Humana Inc. 33% |
| Greene County | 1,639 | 32.1% | Humana Inc. 42% |
| Alleghany County | 1,588 | 34.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 41% |
| Lancaster County | 1,587 | 32.3% | Humana Inc. 30% |
| King George County | 1,562 | 30.0% | Humana Inc. 47% |
| Charlotte County | 1,561 | 44.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 38% |
| Middlesex County | 1,534 | 37.0% | Humana Inc. 38% |
| Essex County | 1,444 | 42.4% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Lunenburg County | 1,441 | 44.7% | Humana Inc. 28% |
| Greensville County | 1,423 | 53.2% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Sussex County | 1,343 | 50.6% | Humana Inc. 47% |
| Franklin City | 1,299 | 59.0% | Elevance Health, Inc. 36% |
| Madison County | 1,298 | 35.7% | Humana Inc. 52% |
| Clarke County | 1,253 | 29.9% | Humana Inc. 45% |
| Radford City | 1,095 | 47.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Cumberland County | 1,076 | 42.1% | Humana Inc. 32% |
| Charles City | 1,001 | 45.5% | Humana Inc. 49% |
| Mathews County | 983 | 30.9% | Humana Inc. 42% |
| Galax City | 961 | 52.0% | Humana Inc. 32% |
| Covington City | 948 | 57.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 38% |
| Surry County | 910 | 45.3% | Humana Inc. 51% |
| Richmond County | 873 | 37.6% | Humana Inc. 46% |
| Bland County | 854 | 46.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 57% |
| Falls Church City | 837 | 31.9% | Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. 38% |
| King and Queen County | 826 | 41.4% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Emporia City | 780 | 61.0% | Humana Inc. 33% |
| Norton City | 772 | 64.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 53% |
| Poquoson City | 761 | 25.4% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Williamsburg City | 757 | 24.6% | Humana Inc. 41% |
| Manassas Park City | 715 | 40.3% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Lexington City | 707 | 41.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 41% |
| Buena Vista City | 701 | 48.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 51% |
| Rappahannock County | 618 | 25.4% | Humana Inc. 52% |
| Craig County | 598 | 41.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43% |
| Bath County | 392 | 27.9% | Humana Inc. 38% |
| Highland County | 274 | 28.8% | Humana Inc. 51% |
| Bedford City | 0 | n/a | |
| Clifton Forge City | 0 | n/a | |
| South Boston City | 0 | n/a | |