| Cuyahoga County | 163,843 | 57.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 27% |
| Franklin County | 119,203 | 56.2% | CVS Health Corporation 29% |
| Hamilton County | 93,871 | 56.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 25% |
| Summit County | 81,593 | 63.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 23% |
| Montgomery County | 74,022 | 61.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 29% |
| Stark County | 65,226 | 69.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 21% |
| Lucas County | 55,401 | 58.1% | CVS Health Corporation 25% |
| Lorain County | 46,143 | 58.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 25% |
| Butler County | 43,506 | 55.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 26% |
| Mahoning County | 39,628 | 64.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 30% |
| Trumbull County | 34,209 | 62.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 26% |
| Lake County | 34,120 | 55.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 22% |
| Clermont County | 28,771 | 59.0% | Humana Inc. 25% |
| Warren County | 25,859 | 52.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 24% |
| Medina County | 25,322 | 55.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 20% |
| Portage County | 24,147 | 64.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 22% |
| Licking County | 22,694 | 55.7% | CVS Health Corporation 28% |
| Delaware County | 20,764 | 47.5% | CVS Health Corporation 40% |
| Clark County | 19,691 | 60.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 36% |
| Fairfield County | 19,630 | 57.9% | CVS Health Corporation 27% |
| Greene County | 18,673 | 49.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 28% |
| Richland County | 16,679 | 54.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 31% |
| Columbiana County | 16,677 | 61.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 25% |
| Wayne County | 14,869 | 56.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 17% |
| Wood County | 14,678 | 52.0% | CVS Health Corporation 34% |
| Tuscarawas County | 14,489 | 64.3% | Elevance Health, Inc. 27% |
| Miami County | 14,485 | 54.8% | Elevance Health, Inc. 29% |
| Ashtabula County | 13,981 | 54.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 39% |
| Muskingum County | 12,759 | 58.1% | CVS Health Corporation 51% |
| Allen County | 12,163 | 50.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 25% |
| Geauga County | 12,017 | 48.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 21% |
| Erie County | 10,736 | 51.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 30% |
| Ross County | 10,055 | 56.5% | Trinity Health Corporation 25% |
| Belmont County | 10,017 | 57.7% | CVS Health Corporation 29% |
| Jefferson County | 9,162 | 53.4% | CVS Health Corporation 37% |
| Marion County | 9,008 | 59.2% | CVS Health Corporation 27% |
| Scioto County | 8,893 | 51.8% | Humana Inc. 31% |
| Knox County | 8,296 | 55.1% | Humana Inc. 32% |
| Hancock County | 7,943 | 46.4% | CVS Health Corporation 54% |
| Washington County | 7,485 | 46.6% | Humana Inc. 25% |
| Ashland County | 7,416 | 57.3% | CVS Health Corporation 22% |
| Lawrence County | 7,399 | 50.3% | Humana Inc. 30% |
| Pickaway County | 7,349 | 58.4% | Trinity Health Corporation 22% |
| Sandusky County | 7,349 | 47.8% | CVS Health Corporation 27% |
| Huron County | 7,256 | 51.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 23% |
| Ottawa County | 6,872 | 52.1% | MEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO 26% |
| Brown County | 6,723 | 61.9% | Humana Inc. 23% |
| Athens County | 6,072 | 52.8% | CVS Health Corporation 35% |
| Union County | 5,962 | 50.8% | CVS Health Corporation 35% |
| Highland County | 5,914 | 57.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 26% |
| Preble County | 5,789 | 56.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 33% |
| Clinton County | 5,770 | 56.6% | Elevance Health, Inc. 27% |
| Seneca County | 5,765 | 42.6% | CVS Health Corporation 44% |
| Crawford County | 5,747 | 50.7% | CVS Health Corporation 34% |
| Madison County | 5,685 | 59.6% | CVS Health Corporation 26% |
| Darke County | 5,511 | 42.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 34% |
| Logan County | 5,445 | 47.4% | CVS Health Corporation 31% |
| Guernsey County | 5,407 | 55.2% | CVS Health Corporation 49% |
| Fulton County | 5,322 | 51.4% | CVS Health Corporation 29% |
| Champaign County | 5,192 | 57.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 33% |
| Defiance County | 5,017 | 51.5% | CVS Health Corporation 40% |
| Perry County | 4,985 | 58.0% | Trinity Health Corporation 24% |
| Coshocton County | 4,804 | 53.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Carroll County | 4,645 | 62.9% | CVS Health Corporation 23% |
| Morrow County | 4,436 | 53.2% | Humana Inc. 29% |
| Williams County | 4,360 | 46.1% | CVS Health Corporation 40% |
| Auglaize County | 4,337 | 39.5% | CVS Health Corporation 33% |
| Jackson County | 4,299 | 54.1% | Humana Inc. 27% |
| Adams County | 4,208 | 60.6% | Elevance Health, Inc. 28% |
| Shelby County | 4,088 | 38.2% | CVS Health Corporation 30% |
| Gallia County | 4,024 | 54.0% | Humana Inc. 28% |
| Hocking County | 3,807 | 54.0% | Elevance Health, Inc. 20% |
| Fayette County | 3,686 | 53.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 24% |
| Pike County | 3,551 | 51.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 28% |
| Meigs County | 3,419 | 57.1% | CVS Health Corporation 28% |
| Hardin County | 3,331 | 51.3% | CVS Health Corporation 32% |
| Van Wert County | 3,304 | 46.9% | CVS Health Corporation 35% |
| Mercer County | 3,215 | 32.2% | CVS Health Corporation 45% |
| Henry County | 3,119 | 45.7% | CVS Health Corporation 48% |
| Putnam County | 3,085 | 37.7% | CVS Health Corporation 32% |
| Holmes County | 2,941 | 51.5% | CVS Health Corporation 24% |
| Wyandot County | 2,568 | 45.3% | CVS Health Corporation 44% |
| Harrison County | 2,315 | 58.3% | CVS Health Corporation 35% |
| Paulding County | 2,248 | 49.5% | CVS Health Corporation 30% |
| Monroe County | 2,228 | 55.2% | Humana Inc. 21% |
| Morgan County | 2,163 | 61.3% | CVS Health Corporation 38% |
| Vinton County | 1,647 | 58.7% | Humana Inc. 23% |
| Noble County | 1,497 | 50.0% | CVS Health Corporation 40% |