| Cook County | 403,219 | 44.9% | Humana Inc. 37% |
| DuPage County | 71,154 | 37.8% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Will County | 52,799 | 41.7% | Humana Inc. 42% |
| Lake County | 47,006 | 34.8% | Humana Inc. 45% |
| Kane County | 38,397 | 40.2% | Humana Inc. 38% |
| Winnebago County | 37,662 | 58.7% | CVS Health Corporation 50% |
| Madison County | 33,630 | 55.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 42% |
| St. Clair County | 30,658 | 55.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43% |
| Sangamon County | 27,119 | 59.3% | CVS Health Corporation 74% |
| McHenry County | 24,819 | 37.0% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Champaign County | 19,787 | 58.8% | CVS Health Corporation 75% |
| Peoria County | 19,651 | 51.3% | Humana Inc. 41% |
| Rock Island County | 19,558 | 59.2% | CVS Health Corporation 50% |
| Tazewell County | 14,216 | 45.4% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| McLean County | 13,739 | 44.3% | CVS Health Corporation 48% |
| Vermilion County | 10,068 | 56.5% | CVS Health Corporation 63% |
| La Salle County | 9,597 | 35.6% | CVS Health Corporation 37% |
| Kankakee County | 9,400 | 39.7% | CVS Health Corporation 39% |
| Macon County | 9,308 | 37.8% | CVS Health Corporation 60% |
| Kendall County | 8,088 | 38.9% | Humana Inc. 50% |
| DeKalb County | 8,030 | 42.5% | CVS Health Corporation 50% |
| Stephenson County | 7,542 | 62.0% | CVS Health Corporation 60% |
| Williamson County | 6,210 | 38.0% | CVS Health Corporation 54% |
| Adams County | 6,042 | 37.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 60% |
| Henry County | 6,000 | 48.3% | CVS Health Corporation 48% |
| Whiteside County | 5,964 | 40.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 47% |
| Knox County | 5,907 | 46.2% | Humana Inc. 36% |
| Ogle County | 5,895 | 47.7% | CVS Health Corporation 57% |
| Boone County | 5,844 | 51.6% | CVS Health Corporation 46% |
| Jackson County | 5,714 | 51.5% | CVS Health Corporation 56% |
| Macoupin County | 5,279 | 44.0% | CVS Health Corporation 42% |
| Coles County | 5,086 | 47.8% | CVS Health Corporation 68% |
| Monroe County | 4,715 | 53.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 38% |
| Franklin County | 4,097 | 41.8% | CVS Health Corporation 40% |
| Jo Daviess County | 4,042 | 57.3% | Medical Associates Clinic, P.C. 50% |
| Christian County | 4,001 | 48.6% | CVS Health Corporation 65% |
| Fulton County | 4,001 | 47.2% | CVS Health Corporation 48% |
| Randolph County | 3,843 | 52.5% | CVS Health Corporation 44% |
| Grundy County | 3,675 | 35.5% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Morgan County | 3,612 | 43.5% | CVS Health Corporation 57% |
| Lee County | 3,520 | 40.1% | CVS Health Corporation 50% |
| Livingston County | 3,484 | 41.0% | Humana Inc. 42% |
| Clinton County | 3,476 | 39.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 52% |
| Marion County | 3,243 | 33.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 48% |
| Woodford County | 3,211 | 36.1% | Humana Inc. 47% |
| Logan County | 2,997 | 46.9% | CVS Health Corporation 57% |
| Montgomery County | 2,922 | 40.3% | CVS Health Corporation 60% |
| Jefferson County | 2,851 | 32.5% | CVS Health Corporation 47% |
| McDonough County | 2,851 | 46.9% | CVS Health Corporation 64% |
| Bureau County | 2,837 | 32.8% | CVS Health Corporation 49% |
| Jersey County | 2,689 | 46.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 53% |
| Iroquois County | 2,413 | 33.2% | CVS Health Corporation 42% |
| Effingham County | 2,379 | 27.8% | CVS Health Corporation 68% |
| Piatt County | 2,336 | 56.0% | CVS Health Corporation 74% |
| Saline County | 2,298 | 37.3% | CVS Health Corporation 45% |
| Perry County | 2,182 | 44.6% | CVS Health Corporation 31% |
| Douglas County | 2,179 | 51.1% | CVS Health Corporation 77% |
| Union County | 2,040 | 44.1% | CVS Health Corporation 62% |
| Mercer County | 1,946 | 45.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 53% |
| Bond County | 1,839 | 48.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 47% |
| Carroll County | 1,804 | 40.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 35% |
| Clark County | 1,736 | 43.9% | CVS Health Corporation 56% |
| Fayette County | 1,733 | 36.6% | CVS Health Corporation 51% |
| Shelby County | 1,675 | 31.2% | CVS Health Corporation 67% |
| Menard County | 1,659 | 54.5% | CVS Health Corporation 66% |
| De Witt County | 1,621 | 41.6% | CVS Health Corporation 48% |
| Edgar County | 1,597 | 35.2% | CVS Health Corporation 44% |
| Warren County | 1,484 | 38.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 33% |
| Mason County | 1,474 | 41.5% | CVS Health Corporation 53% |
| Johnson County | 1,390 | 43.2% | CVS Health Corporation 63% |
| Hancock County | 1,313 | 26.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 32% |
| Marshall County | 1,246 | 38.1% | Humana Inc. 41% |
| Pike County | 1,217 | 32.1% | CVS Health Corporation 46% |
| Greene County | 1,192 | 40.4% | CVS Health Corporation 49% |
| Crawford County | 1,185 | 25.8% | CVS Health Corporation 54% |
| Ford County | 1,171 | 34.8% | CVS Health Corporation 60% |
| Massac County | 1,160 | 30.5% | CVS Health Corporation 41% |
| Moultrie County | 1,137 | 34.0% | CVS Health Corporation 72% |
| Cumberland County | 1,129 | 41.9% | CVS Health Corporation 74% |
| Richland County | 1,121 | 28.8% | CVS Health Corporation 49% |
| Cass County | 1,116 | 41.3% | CVS Health Corporation 60% |
| Washington County | 1,107 | 31.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 46% |
| White County | 1,065 | 28.6% | CVS Health Corporation 42% |
| Wayne County | 969 | 24.8% | CVS Health Corporation 46% |
| Lawrence County | 897 | 27.0% | CVS Health Corporation 44% |
| Clay County | 842 | 25.3% | CVS Health Corporation 61% |
| Alexander County | 720 | 51.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 51% |
| Jasper County | 694 | 27.7% | CVS Health Corporation 65% |
| Schuyler County | 662 | 38.2% | CVS Health Corporation 66% |
| Wabash County | 633 | 22.1% | CVS Health Corporation 45% |
| Henderson County | 618 | 34.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43% |
| Hamilton County | 609 | 31.3% | CVS Health Corporation 50% |
| Pulaski County | 587 | 41.8% | CVS Health Corporation 50% |
| Stark County | 557 | 40.1% | CVS Health Corporation 38% |
| Putnam County | 515 | 31.7% | CVS Health Corporation 45% |
| Calhoun County | 500 | 39.2% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 46% |
| Scott County | 451 | 40.8% | CVS Health Corporation 73% |
| Gallatin County | 450 | 33.3% | CVS Health Corporation 37% |
| Pope County | 425 | 35.6% | CVS Health Corporation 57% |
| Brown County | 419 | 36.6% | CVS Health Corporation 67% |
| Edwards County | 342 | 20.9% | CVS Health Corporation 52% |
| Hardin County | 329 | 32.5% | CVS Health Corporation 57% |