| Jefferson County | 76,795 | 62.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 48% |
| El Paso County | 67,431 | 51.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 49% |
| Arapahoe County | 62,746 | 57.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43% |
| Denver County | 59,589 | 59.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 36% |
| Adams County | 47,338 | 64.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43% |
| Larimer County | 37,583 | 47.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 48% |
| Douglas County | 34,184 | 50.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 48% |
| Weld County | 32,405 | 56.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 40% |
| Boulder County | 31,125 | 47.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 49% |
| Pueblo County | 25,681 | 62.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 57% |
| Mesa County | 19,239 | 45.8% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Fremont County | 8,146 | 59.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 67% |
| Broomfield County | 8,118 | 61.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 44% |
| Montrose County | 5,435 | 41.2% | Humana Inc. 58% |
| Delta County | 4,985 | 46.7% | Humana Inc. 57% |
| La Plata County | 4,163 | 30.2% | CVS Health Corporation 51% |
| Teller County | 4,102 | 53.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 52% |
| Elbert County | 3,196 | 48.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 39% |
| Otero County | 2,938 | 60.6% | Humana Inc. 67% |
| Montezuma County | 2,567 | 32.5% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 36% |
| Morgan County | 2,282 | 39.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 40% |
| Las Animas County | 2,265 | 48.9% | Humana Inc. 47% |
| Chaffee County | 2,219 | 35.0% | Humana Inc. 34% |
| Park County | 2,003 | 43.2% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Logan County | 1,789 | 38.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 52% |
| Alamosa County | 1,556 | 45.1% | Humana Inc. 53% |
| Rio Grande County | 1,412 | 39.0% | Humana Inc. 58% |
| Archuleta County | 1,407 | 29.0% | CVS Health Corporation 35% |
| Huerfano County | 1,402 | 51.4% | Humana Inc. 38% |
| Eagle County | 1,341 | 16.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 90% |
| Garfield County | 1,330 | 12.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 92% |
| Clear Creek County | 1,183 | 52.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 54% |
| Conejos County | 1,090 | 52.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 34% |
| Grand County | 1,073 | 32.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 42% |
| Summit County | 996 | 21.8% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 71% |
| Custer County | 907 | 41.7% | Humana Inc. 40% |
| Saguache County | 793 | 48.9% | Humana Inc. 43% |
| Routt County | 788 | 15.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 49% |
| Costilla County | 774 | 54.8% | Humana Inc. 41% |
| Gilpin County | 680 | 49.9% | Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. 34% |
| Gunnison County | 592 | 19.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 45% |
| Bent County | 563 | 48.5% | Humana Inc. 64% |
| Rio Blanco County | 477 | 31.2% | Humana Inc. 62% |
| Crowley County | 474 | 51.7% | Humana Inc. 55% |
| Prowers County | 452 | 17.1% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 97% |
| Ouray County | 434 | 23.5% | Humana Inc. 51% |
| Lake County | 392 | 34.0% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 55% |
| Lincoln County | 348 | 31.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 38% |
| Washington County | 338 | 28.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 40% |
| Moffat County | 323 | 11.7% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 88% |
| Pitkin County | 281 | 7.8% | Devoted Health, Inc. 56% |
| San Miguel County | 280 | 20.8% | Humana Inc. 64% |
| Yuma County | 264 | 12.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 100% |
| Kit Carson County | 207 | 12.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 100% |
| Dolores County | 181 | 28.9% | Humana Inc. 67% |
| Phillips County | 175 | 17.4% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 100% |
| Mineral County | 108 | 33.9% | Humana Inc. 50% |
| Jackson County | 88 | 25.4% | Humana Inc. 70% |
| Baca County | 80 | 8.3% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 100% |
| Kiowa County | 75 | 19.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 100% |
| Sedgwick County | 74 | 9.6% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 100% |
| Hinsdale County | 68 | 27.6% | Humana Inc. 41% |
| Cheyenne County | 49 | 11.9% | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 100% |
| San Juan County | 32 | 18.7% | Humana Inc. 100% |